“51% US made” is not the test under any federal rule a red light device will meet. Buy American asks two questions: was the product manufactured in the US, and do domestic components exceed a set share of component cost. The Trade Agreements Act asks a different question with no percentage at all. Which one applies depends on the contract, not the product.
A buyer in the veterans or DME channel often arrives with a number: half, 51 percent, “majority US content”. The number usually comes from somewhere real, but rarely from the rule that governs their contract. Building a supply chain to the wrong number is an expensive way to fail an eligibility check.
This guide separates the two rules, shows how to tell which one your contract uses, and walks through the Buy American component test on a red light panel. It is part of our country of origin series.
Buy American: the end product must be manufactured in the US, and domestic components must exceed 65 percent of component cost, a threshold scheduled to rise to 75 percent. TAA: the product must be US-made or come from a designated country; there is no percentage, and China is not a designated country. Small business set-asides and smaller purchases generally fall under Buy American. Larger covered contracts and most schedule sales fall under TAA.
Two rules, two different questions
| Buy American | Trade Agreements Act | |
|---|---|---|
| Core question | Is it a domestic end product? | Is it a US-made or designated country end product? |
| Test | Manufactured in the US, plus domestic components exceeding a set share of component cost | Made in, or substantially transformed in, the US or a designated country |
| Percentage | 65 percent, scheduled to rise to 75 percent; set by delivery year in FAR 25.101 | None |
| Foreign products | Can still be bought, but evaluated with a price penalty against domestic offers | Products from non-designated countries such as China generally cannot be bought |
| Typical scope | Purchases below the TAA threshold, small business set-asides | Covered purchases above the threshold, GSA schedules in practice |
| FAR clause to look for | 52.225-1, Buy American, Supplies | 52.225-5, Trade Agreements |
The two rules can give opposite answers for the same device. A panel whose LED board is populated in Taiwan can be a designated country product under TAA and a foreign end product under Buy American, because it was not manufactured in the US. A panel assembled in the US from foreign boards can fail Buy American’s component test and still be argued as US-made under TAA. That is why the contract clause comes first.
Which rule your contract uses
Work through it in this order, and confirm each answer with the contracting officer.
Five questions before you design the supply chain
- Is it a small business set-aside? FAR 25.401 excludes set-asides from TAA coverage. Buy American generally applies.
- Is the estimated value below the TAA threshold? The WTO GPA supply threshold sits at $174,000 at the latest biennial adjustment, with lower thresholds under several Free Trade Agreements. Below them, Buy American generally applies.
- Is it a GSA schedule? Schedules are valued as whole contracts, so TAA nearly always applies, even to single-unit orders.
- Is it a covered acquisition above the threshold? TAA applies, and the Buy American restrictions are waived for designated country products.
- Read the clauses. The solicitation will include 52.225-1, 52.225-5 or a related clause. The clause decides which rule you are building to.
A distributor selling the same panel through a schedule and through a small business set-aside can face both rules in the same quarter. Plan the federal SKU around the stricter combination, or plan two SKUs.
Where “51%” comes from
For decades the Buy American component test required domestic components to exceed 50 percent of component cost. “51 percent” is the everyday way of saying “more than half”, and it survives in buyer conversations long after the rule moved on.
The threshold has since been raised more than once: to 55, then 60, then 65 percent, with 75 percent scheduled. A temporary 55 percent fallback can apply when an agency finds no domestic offer meeting the higher threshold, or finds such offers unreasonably priced, but it is the agency’s call, not a design target.
And “51%” was never a TAA concept. TAA has no content percentage. A buyer asking for both “TAA compliant” and “51% US made” is describing two different rules, and the supply chain that satisfies one may not satisfy the other.
Verification rule: when a buyer quotes a percentage, ask which clause is in the solicitation. The answer tells you whether the percentage matters at all, and which percentage it is.
Running the Buy American test on a red light panel
The component test has a structure that surprises most buyers. The FAR defines a component as an article incorporated directly into the end product. A component manufactured in the US is counted as domestic at its full cost. Components of unknown origin are treated as foreign.
For a red light panel, that makes the populated boards the decisive line items. Here is the method on a hypothetical BOM. The cost shares are invented round numbers to show the arithmetic, not data from any real product.
| Component incorporated directly | Share of component cost (hypothetical) | Layout 1: boards made in China, housing made in US | Layout 2: boards populated in US from imported parts, housing made in US |
|---|---|---|---|
| LED PCBA | 45% | Foreign | Domestic |
| Driver and control PCBA | 20% | Foreign | Domestic |
| Steel housing | 15% | Domestic | Domestic |
| External power supply | 10% | Foreign | Foreign |
| Cables, goggles, mounting hardware | 10% | Foreign | Foreign |
| Domestic share | 15%: fails | 80%: passes 65% |
Hypothetical cost shares for illustrating the method. Not a RedVance BOM and not a ruling on any product.
Layout 2 passes even though every LED and chip on those boards was imported, because the boards themselves are manufactured in the US. That is the practical meaning of the definition: Buy American follows where the boards are populated more than where the LEDs are bought. Confirm the treatment of your actual BOM with trade counsel before relying on it.
Two further points from FAR 25.101:
- Manufactured in the US comes first. A product finished abroad fails Buy American regardless of its component content.
- COTS items skip the component test. For most commercially available off-the-shelf end products, the domestic content test is waived, so a COTS panel manufactured in the US can be a domestic end product without the 65 percent calculation. That puts the weight back on “manufactured”, which, as with TAA, has no published line for simple electronics assembly.
The same five layouts under both rules
These layouts follow our TAA guide. The assessments are reasoning from the FAR text, published CBP rulings and case law, not rulings on any product.
| Layout | Buy American | TAA |
|---|---|---|
| A. Finished panel made in China | Foreign | Not compliant |
| B. LED PCBA made in China, simple final assembly in Taiwan or Mexico | Foreign not manufactured in the US | Likely not |
| C. LED PCBA populated in Taiwan or Mexico, other parts from China | Foreign not manufactured in the US | Likely compliant designated country product |
| D. LED PCBA from China, final assembly in the US | Likely fails component test, unless COTS; “manufactured” question open | Uncertain depends on agency view of US manufacturing |
| E. Boards populated and panel assembled in the US | Strong case subject to the component test or COTS waiver | Strong case |
Layout C is the trap. It is the cleanest TAA route for a brand that wants to keep costs down, and it fails Buy American outright. If any of your federal volume comes through set-asides or below-threshold buys, layout C alone will not cover it.
Layout E is the only one that holds up under both rules. It is also the most expensive to set up, which is exactly why the question deserves an answer before tooling, not after the first award.
The mechanics of layout D, and why final assembly alone so rarely changes the answer, are covered in Does US Final Assembly Change a Red Light Device’s Origin?
Where RedVance stands
Our LED and driver boards are populated in Shenzhen and our panels are finished there. Under Buy American, a panel we build is a foreign end product, and the boards we supply count as foreign components. Under TAA, it is not compliant. We say that before quoting, not after.
Many brands run a commercial line and a federal line from different supply chains. Our OEM/ODM programme serves the commercial side as normal. For a federal SKU, whether any of our engineering or documentation work has a place in a layout C or E chain is a project-specific question that your contracting officer and trade counsel need to answer first. The supplier structures that make that split workable are covered in why brands use multiple suppliers per product line.
The origin series
Frequently asked questions
How do I verify whether Buy American or TAA applies to my red light contract?
Read the clauses in the solicitation and confirm with the contracting officer. Clause 52.225-1 points to Buy American and 52.225-5 to the Trade Agreements Act. Small business set-asides and purchases below the TAA threshold generally fall under Buy American; covered purchases above it and most GSA schedule sales fall under TAA.
How do I verify whether a red light panel meets the Buy American domestic content test?
Confirm the panel is manufactured in the US, then list every component incorporated directly into it with its cost and where it was manufactured. Domestic components must exceed the threshold in FAR 25.101, which is 65 percent and scheduled to rise to 75 percent. Components of unknown origin count as foreign.
How do I verify whether “51% US made” is the right requirement?
Ask which clause the contract uses. The Buy American threshold has been above 50 percent for some time and is 65 percent, and TAA uses no percentage. A 51 percent figure usually reflects the old Buy American rule rather than the current requirement.
How do I verify whether a TAA compliant red light device also meets Buy American?
Check where it was manufactured. A device made in a designated country such as Taiwan or Mexico can be TAA compliant and still be a foreign end product under Buy American, because Buy American requires manufacturing in the US plus the domestic component test.
How do I verify whether imported LEDs make a panel fail Buy American?
Look at the components incorporated directly into the panel. If the LED boards are populated in the US, the FAR treats them as components manufactured in the US and counts them as domestic at full cost, even when the LEDs on them were imported. Confirm the treatment of your specific BOM with trade counsel.
How do I verify whether a COTS red light panel needs the component test?
FAR 25.101 waives the domestic content test for most commercially available off-the-shelf end products, so a COTS panel manufactured in the US can qualify as domestic without the cost calculation. It still has to be manufactured in the US, and how much US work counts as manufacturing for electronics is not clearly defined.
Send us the clause. We will tell you which rule you are building to.
Share the solicitation clause, the device and where each production step is planned. We will show which line items decide the Buy American and TAA answers, give you the BOM and process data for anything we would build, and say plainly if our part of the chain keeps the product from qualifying.
Start a federal sourcing review →Buy American general rule and domestic content thresholds: FAR 25.101
Definitions of component and domestic end product: FAR 25.003
Exceptions to TAA coverage: FAR 25.401
Trade agreements thresholds: Federal Register
Threshold schedule and fallback: Kelley Drye, Buy American final rule
The earlier 50 percent component test: Sheppard Mullin, Acetris analysis
EN